Monday, July 1, 2013

Evan Walker Feed back on Headsail Trim


Headsail Trim 101     DRAFT 13/06/13
Evan Walker 3 June 2013

Step 1:
Sit down to leeward (on the side of the boat away from the wind, also known as the low side of the boat) and while on an upwind course, trim to an obviously under-trimmed position (top of the jib flapping while the bottom is filled).

Step 2:
The skipper will use the bottom tell-tales (See figure 1) as a steering guide so those will fly parallel. Now notice that the middle and/or top windward tell-tales are breaking (not flying parallel). This shows that the top of the jib is sheeted out too much compared to the bottom of the jib and the jib is described as having too much twist.

Step 3:
It is helpful to think of the jib sheet as controlling the headsail twist. If you sheet on more the twist will decrease. Slowly sheet on (with the skipper maintaining an upwind course according to the bottom tell-tales) and only stop when the middle tell-tales stop breaking. Now the middle (and top) of the jib are working properly along with the bottom. The twist is correct.

Step 4:
As the skipper slowly steers up above this course, the middle tell-tales should break slightly before the bottom ones (If they break at the same time it will be difficult for the skipper to steer). If the top breaks too early relative to the bottom, correct the twist by sheeting on a bit more.

Step 5:
Now that the twist is correct, pay attention to the depth in the foot (bottom) of the jib. You may need to be shown a few times what is an appropriate depth for underpowered conditions (when you want max power) and what the foot should look like when you want it fully depowered (flat). This can be controlled by adjusting the jib carr.
(Most jibs like the Sydney38 Medium have a ‘shelf’ foot.  This means the gap between the depth of the foot and the straight line between the tack and the clew is filled in with material. When you want full power this shelf should look like it was meant to, with the edge of the sail pulled almost straight from tack to clew.)

Step 6:
If once you have sheeted the jib for the correct amount of twist, the foot is too deep, you need to move the jib carr back (away from the bow, so that the sheet is effectively pulling more along the foot instead of down the leech) and vice versa. As the wind increases and you get more and more over powered, you will need to flatten the foot by moving the carr further back incrementally (If you move the carr too far back you risk tearing the foot apart).

Step 7:
Moving the carr also affects the twist so now re-adjust the jib sheet to achieve optimum twist. If you still aren’t happy with the foot depth repeat steps 6 and 7.

Step 8:
Now while you are getting used to this process it might take a long time and you don’t want to have to repeat it every time you tack, so pay attention to the carr position and where the leech of the jib is compared to the bands on the bottom spreader. An alternative (or additional) method to using the spreader bands to replicate sheet settings is to put a mark on the sheets near the winch when they are fully sheeted.

Advanced step 9: Barber haulers
Once the twist and the depth have been set, the barber hauler can be used to sheet the whole sail in closer to the centre line of the boat. This will help the boat sail closer to the wind but might cost some speed.  The easiest way to use them is to keep an eye on the boat speed instrument. If the boat is faster than the target boat speed when the skipper steers to the tell tales then you can probably pull on more barber hauler.
Another thing to notice is the leech tales (Figure 1). These are the tell-tales extending off the back of the leech.  If the leech returns too much towards the centreline (is too hooked), either because of too much barber hauler or too much jib sheet, these leech tales will suck in behind the sail and not fly freely. Similarly, if they are flying all the time then you can potentially pull on more barber hauler (or sheet), so make adjustments until you see them start to suck behind occasionally.
A sure sign that you have too much barber hauler is that the bottom of the mainsail luff will suffer from ‘blow-back’ (bubbles). See diagram 2. If there is blow-back and the barber hauler is already fully eased you need to either ease the sheet a bit, or if you also think the foot is too deep, just move the jib carr back (flattening the foot while also increasing twist). The middle tell-tales will now break early but that’s ok because the boat is overpowered.

Barber hauler can have an affect on both jib depth and twist, so after any adjustments to barber hauler re-adjust sheet and carr to return to desired depth and twist.

Advanced step 10: Backstay
As the wind increases you will notice the forestay will tend to ‘sag’ more to leeward and sometimes you will see it move around a lot in waves. It is never good for parts of the sail to move around a lot and it is also not good for the forestay to sag excessively. Changes in sag affect the shape of the sail according to Figure 3.  To maintain an acceptable amount of sag ask the main trimmer to adjust the backstay. More backstay means less sag. You will have to accommodate the main trimmer however because the backstay also affects the depth of the mainsail by bending the mast.

Advanced step 11: Headsail halyard
Similar to forestay sag, headsail halyard tension can have a big effect on sail shape. A tighter halyard will move the shape towards the front of the sail (Figure 4). This might be beneficial in choppy water or in stronger winds. It can also help correct the effect of age. As sails get older the shape moves further aft (back).
A good starting point is to tighten the halyard until there is only a hint of horizontal creases in the luff. This will vary as the wind strength changes.
It is important to be able to replicate the halyard setting every time the jib is hoisted, and if you have changed headsails on the last run you need to have a starting point for the new sail’s halyard tension.
The easiest way to keep track of this is to have an area of stickyback on the sliding hatch. On it draw a table with wind strength down the side, and sail selection across the top (Light Medium Heavy). It is then the pitperson’s responsibility to record the setting whenever the trimmer is happy with it. Within a couple of sessions the table should be close to complete.

Mechanics of headsail trim
Only use the self-tailer on the winch if the load is too heavy to wind with one hand and it is inconvenient to give the tail to the offside trimmer. For any big trim moments like the wind up at the start or the bottom mark, or after a big dip, the offside trimmer should make themself available (just turn your shoulders in and reach your hand out).

Always take the handle out of the winch once you have reached target trim, and cleat the sheet on the inside of the cockpit. Putting it in the tailer means you need more time to leeward going into a tack.

When you need to add a wrap, always try to have the handle aiming towards you so you don’t have to reach over it.

Upon exiting the tack (immediately after tacking), the trimmer should pay close attention to the jib tell-tales and only trim the jib to match the angle steered by the skipper. There are a number of reasons why the skipper might steer higher or lower than usual out of a tack. If they come out too low, trim to that angle, and then wait til they steer up before trimming in any more (But be careful not to undertrim when easing to the skipper’s course. Can can lead to the skipper steering further away from the wind).
It’s also important to have a slightly softer (looser) trim while the boat is building speed, then wind up to your target trim only once the boat has reached the target boat speed.

When tacking, the offside trimmer should move across the front of the cockpit while the trimmer steps behind.
At all times both trimmers should be conscious of their weight. Offside should tail as far across the boat (to windward) as possible (unless the weight needs to be to leeward out of the tack such as in light winds). After turning legs in the trimmer should stay to windward til the last second before the tack and then after trimming to the tack exit/speed build setting, should move to windward with the tail where you can see the jib tell-tales from the windward side of the mast, here you can ease more sheet if necessary during the speed build before returning to leeward to wind in the last bit once the boat approaches target speed (In strong winds you might take a long time to get the sheet in. In this case don’t worry about moving to the windward side for the speed build).


Recording Settings:
It is important to keep track of what carr/spreader band/barber haul combination you used for each wind strength. The optimum setting will change across the wind range and might be completely different for each jib used. Get in the habit of carrying a notepad to record quick notes while sailing and then consolidating these along with the halyard settings at the end of the day.


Super Advanced Sail Shape and the influence of mast bend and forestay tension:
There are two ways that sail makers build shape into any upwind sail. These are known as broadseam shape and luff curve shape.
o   Broadseam shape is built into a sail in the way that the various panels in the sail are joined together. On any seam, shape is introduced to the sail when one edge is cut in a slight convex curve and the adjacent panel is cut straight. This type of shape accounts for most of the shape in the sail.
o   Luff curve shape is the same technique on a much larger scale along the luff of the sale. When the luff, which is prominently convex curved, is forced onto a straight mast, shape is introduced to the sail. The benefit of luff curve shape is that we can easily influence it by bending the mast for a mainsail, or changing forestay sag for a jib.

The mast can be bent by pulling on the backstay. The more backstay you pull on the more the mast bends and the more closely the bend of the mast matches the luff curve, producing a flatter sail. This reaches a limit when the mast bend matches the luff curve. Over bend creases will occur if the mast is bent any more (Figure 5).

The backstay also affects the tension in the forestay. This combined with the load in the sail determines the amount the forestay sags. Forestay sag affects a jib in a similar way that mast bend affects a mainsail. The more the forestay sags, the more luff curve shape the sail will have. More accurately it affects the ‘angle of entry’. This is the angle between the wind coming into the sail and the front of the sail. Forestay sag affects the ‘angle of entry’ in the middle of the jib luff more than it does the top and the bottom. Therefore, excessive forestay sag might result in a middle tell-tale that breaks before both the top and bottom tell-tales.

No comments:

Post a Comment